Almost one year ago from today I started off a post in this manner …
Will the real American Golden Plover please stand up?!
Some of us are old enough to remember the TV show, To Tell The Truth! In this show, a panel of celebrities asked three guests questions in an attempt to determine who was the real guest, and who were impostors. Sometimes identifying shorebirds feels a bit like an episode of this game show. Shorebirds have many different plumage patterns, which vary by the season of the year, and whether a bird is a male, female, breeding male, breeding female or an immature bird.
Well … ID’ing shorebirds and specifically the difference between American Golden and Black Bellied Plovers is very, very tough. I did manage to come up with a correct ID for all the birds featured in this post, but I checked my work using both of these two tools:
I assume most of my readers have similar problems with Shorebird identification. Hope these two resources help.
Ruddy Turnstones
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7a5ef/7a5efc76d06730876fa26f096f7a4c4ea0becb43" alt=""
Sanderlings
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4af48/4af48f72aa6ad7ceed7cd1593f8c1d9aaed7ffd6" alt=""
American Golden Plovers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dad1c/dad1c1f4b15cf3b5207d8afda90ac6205597ca51" alt=""
And some non shorebirds that wanted in on the post. Images also taken out on Minnesota Point!
Common Crowdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dcae7/dcae74366d346968fbfc524ddb396eb11f45ede4" alt=""
Palm Warblerdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/266b6/266b6e76c7099ef50b8fe53d6bc601313c4bf9d1" alt=""